Mandolin Wide Nut vs. Standard Nut: What's the Difference?

When ordering a Northfield mandolin, you'll encounter a choice between standard and wide nut options across most of their model lines. While this decision generates considerable discussion among players, understanding the actual differences can help you make an informed choice.

The Technical Difference

Northfield's standard nut measures 1-1/8" (1.125"), while the wide nut option measures 1-3/16" (1.1875").

This 1/16" difference represents about a 5.2% increase in width, which translates to slightly more spacing between the string pairs.

Playability Considerations

The extra spacing in a wide nut primarily affects how your fretting hand interacts with the strings.

Players often notice the difference most when performing intricate single-note melodies or complex chord work, where the additional space can reduce accidental contact between fingers and adjacent strings.

When it comes to picking, the difference is generally less noticeable since the string spacing at the bridge remains unchanged.

 However, these benefits are modest and the difference isn't dramatic enough to fundamentally change your playing capabilities.

Player Preferences

Over the years, I've observed wide nuts become increasingly popular among mandolin players.

Players with larger hands or thicker fingers frequently report that the wide nut feels more comfortable, but plenty of players with average-sized hands also appreciate the extra space and find it more forgiving.

Those coming from guitar often find the wider spacing more comfortable, even though mandolin string spacing remains much tighter than guitar.

However, hand size isn't necessarily predictive. Many players with larger hands play standard nuts comfortably, while some with smaller hands prefer the wide option. Playing style and personal preference often matter more than physical dimensions.

Making Your Choice

The wide nut has steadily gained popularity in recent years, with many players finding the extra spacing more comfortable and forgiving.

That said, both nut width options are completely viable, and the difference is less dramatic than some online discussions might suggest. I have found that most players can adapt to either width after a relatively short adjustment period. 

If you're uncertain, the wide nut could be considered a safer choice, but I encourage my customers not to overthink it. In my humble opinion, factors like build quality and setup have more bearing on playability than a 1/16" difference in nut width.